Skip to content
The Catering FinderFinding the perfect caterer, simplified

Coney Island Stillwater

Caterer in Stillwater, Oklahoma — 3.9 ★

3.9

Rating data sourced from Google Maps

Stillwater, Oklahoma
Corporate EventBar Service

About Coney Island Stillwater

Coney Island Stillwater, a cherished local staple since 1969, extends its tradition of delicious food and fun to your next gathering with dedicated catering services. From their iconic "Best Wieners Since '69" and classic American fare like burgers, crispy wings, and tots, their catering menu also impressively expands to include upscale selections such as steaks and lobster. Ideal for corporate events, Coney Island Stillwater also offers comprehensive bar service, featuring a variety of craft and draft beers, mixed drinks, and shots to complement any occasion. They are known for providing an affordable and memorable experience, ensuring your guests enjoy top-notch eats and drinks that have been a Stillwater favorite for over 50 years.

Specialties & how they serve

Event & client focus

Characteristics

Each chip opens matching listings in the directory.

Contact Information

223 S Washington St, Stillwater, OK 74074

Stillwater, Oklahoma 74074

+1 405-743-1262
Visit Website

Social Media

Request a Custom Quote

Tell Coney Island Stillwater about your event and receive a tailored proposal.

Customer reviews

3.9
3.9

Rating data sourced from Google Maps

Reviews are moderated before appearing.

Be the first to share your experience.

Compare more caterers in Stillwater

More caterers in Stillwater, Oklahoma

All caterers in Stillwater, OklahomaAll caterers in Oklahoma

Duncan Catering Co - Catering in Stillwater, Oklahoma

Duncan Catering Co

4.9

Stillwater, Oklahoma

+4

Duncan Catering Co. delivers delicious, scratch-made catering services across Stillwater, Tulsa, Oklahoma City, and surrounding areas, ensuring every meal is hot, ready, and done right. Specializing in corporate events, reliable business lunches, and full-service weddings, they also offer convenient daily hot lunches, heat & eat meals, and custom bakery desserts. With comprehensive event planning included, along with professional bar service and waitstaff, Duncan Catering Co. makes event coordination seamless and stress-free. Renowned for their outstanding customer service and affordable options, they are consistently voted Stillwater's best caterer and boast a top pastry chef. They craft fully customized packages to match any budget and style, providing exceptional food and service for any occasion.

Backstage Stillwater - Catering in Stillwater, Oklahoma

Backstage Stillwater

4.8

Stillwater, Oklahoma

+2

Backstage Stillwater provides a truly unique and premium catering experience within an inspiring event space. This upscale venue, rich with 120 years of integrated art, architecture, and craftsmanship, invites guests to reflect on the past while drawing inspiration for the present and future. Ideal for corporate events, Backstage Stillwater fosters an environment that encourages new thoughts, fresh perspectives, and innovative plans, perfect for impactful business meetings and gatherings. Elevate any occasion with their sophisticated bar service, ensuring a refined experience for all attendees. Choosing Backstage Stillwater means providing a distinctive setting that sparks creativity and leaves a lasting impression on your guests.

Persimmon Hill Farm and Bakery - Catering in Stillwater, Oklahoma

Persimmon Hill Farm and Bakery

4.8

Stillwater, Oklahoma

+2

Persimmon Hill Farm and Bakery, a family-owned establishment in Stillwater, OK since 2004, brings fresh, local flavors to your table. They offer catering services perfect for corporate events and business lunches. Their menu features an array of homemade baked goods, including various scones, cookies, pastries, pies, cakes, and sandwiches, all crafted with care. Guests can also enjoy their signature local honey, along with delicious jams and jellies. Persimmon Hill Farm and Bakery proudly accommodates dietary needs with a wide variety of gluten-free options, such as cinnamon rolls, scones, cakes, and pies. Committed to freshness, all orders are prepared for convenient pickup at their Stillwater location.

Back to Search