Skip to content
The Catering FinderFinding the perfect caterer, simplified

Schultzy's Restaurant

Caterer in Bayville, New York — 4.8 ★

4.8

Rating data sourced from Google Maps

Bayville, New York
Full Service CateringBuffetCorporate Event

About Schultzy's Restaurant

Schultzy's Restaurant provides premium off-premise seafood catering, transforming corporate events, business lunches, and festive gatherings into unforgettable experiences across Long Island. They specialize in the highest-quality lobsters, steaks, shrimp, and the freshest oysters and clams harvested directly from local waters. Guests can indulge in spectacular raw bars, traditional clambakes, and bountiful buffet-style feasts featuring succulent seafood and gourmet appetizers like Lobster Roll Sliders and Fire-Roasted Oysters. With professional waitstaff included, Schultzy's ensures a seamless and upscale dining experience, delivering fresh, flavorful, and extraordinary culinary delights for any special occasion.

In Bayville, NY, a typical 100-guest buffet runs about $5,225–$10,745 ($52.00 – $107.00 per person). Open cost calculator

Specialties & how they serve

Service formats

  • Plated / Fine dining

Ask Schultzy's Restaurant

Share your date, guest count, and preferences—free, no obligation.

Contact

265 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709

Bayville, New York 11709

+1 516-588-6240
info@longislandrawbar.com
Website

Social

Customer reviews

4.8
4.8

Rating data sourced from Google Maps

Reviews are moderated before appearing.

Be the first to share your experience.

More caterers in Bayville, New York

All caterers in Bayville, New YorkAll caterers in New York

Plates Catering - Catering in Larchmont, New York

Plates Catering

4.8

Larchmont, New York

+2

Plates Catering delivers a versatile and premium catering experience, expertly handling everything from uptown elegant affairs to lively BBQ throwdowns. As dedicated BBQ specialists, they bring exceptional flavors to any gathering, ensuring memorable moments for events of all sizes. Their extensive menu options encompass sophisticated dinner and brunch selections, comprehensive wedding catering, and vibrant cocktail party provisions, along with convenient "by the tray" services. Plates Catering also provides professional bar service, completing the upscale experience for any occasion. Their commitment is always to deliver great food that truly elevates special events.

View profile
Depot Dave Catering - Catering in Pelham, New York

Depot Dave Catering

4.7

Pelham, New York

+7

Depot Dave Catering, a family-owned business established in 2000 by Certified Executive Chef David Katz, brings extensive culinary experience from fine New York and New Jersey country clubs to every private dining experience. Specializing in elegant, customized menus, they offer comprehensive event planning services to ensure your occasion is truly unforgettable across the Tri-State Area. From Tent & Garden Weddings and Bar & Bat Mitzvahs to Graduation Parties and sophisticated Cocktail Parties, Depot Dave excels at creating memorable buffets or sit-down meals. As certified BBQ specialists, they craft gourmet picnics and barbecues, alongside delicious gluten-free options. Their premium, upscale service includes professional bar service, waitstaff, and equipment rental, a testament to why they were named Best Caterer in the Best of Westchester 2025.

View profile

Also in Bayville

Back to Search